|Truth or Myth:
The Legend of Miss Ann and Captain Hawkins
Oak Hill, Fairfax County, Virginia
by Debbie Robison |
December 18, 2014
A legend is told in the
communities surrounding Oak Hill about Miss Ann Fitzhugh who died protecting
her English love, Captain Charles Hawkins. Oak Hill, commonly called “Miss
Ann’s Mansion,” is located near Annandale, VA. The story was documented by Mrs.
Edward F. Howrey and published in the Historical Society of Fairfax Yearbook in
The Howreys owned Oak Hill from 1935 to 1968.
The tale goes like this.
Oak Hill Attic, now a finished living space
|So is there any truth to the legend?|
Myth: The legend states that Ann Fitzhugh and Captain Charles Hawkins met when the area was part of the British colonies. Therefore, according to the legend, they would have met prior the signing of the Declaration of Independence in 1776.
Truth: Miss Ann Fitzhugh did live at Oak Hill. She was the daughter of Richard Fitzhugh, who built Oak Hill. However, Ann was born ca. 1805, which was 29 years after the signing of the Declaration of Independence and 16 years after adoption of the United States Constitution.
Myth: Englishman Captain Charles Hawkins was sent to America to put down a rebellion. Ann hid him at Oak Hill.
Truth:Oak Hill was constructed ca. 1793 after Ann’s father, Richard Fitzhugh, inherited the property from his father. A plat of the property prepared for the land division in December 1792, indicates a number of dwellings; however, Oak Hill is not one of them, thus suggesting that the house wasn't constructed yet. Richard Fitzhugh moved to Fairfax County in 1793. Ann could not have hidden Hawkins at Oak Hill during the Revolutionary war since the house didn’t exist at that time. If the rebellion referred to in the legend was the War of 1812, which resulted in British soldiers in the region in 1814, then Ann would have been only 9 years old.
Myth: Captain Charles Hawkins was Miss Ann’s lover.
Truth: It is unknown if there was a British Captain Charles Hawkins; however, the Alexandria Gazette mentions a Captain Charles Hawkins in 1842. He was an officer of the Alexandria Sharp-Shooters. There isn’t any evidence found to date to show that Captain Charles Hawkins of Alexandria knew Miss Ann Fitzhugh.
Myth: Miss Ann was killed by a soldier using a sabre or bayonet.
 Mrs. Edward F. Howrey, “Oak Hill (near Burke Station),” Historical Society of Fairfax County, Virignia,Inc., ed. A. Smith Bowman, Jr. Katherine S. Shands, and Robert A. Alden, Vol. 7 — 1960-1961, The Independent Printers, Vienna, Virginia, 1961, pp. 34-37.
 Fairfax County Deed Book V11(282)46, June 20, 1935; Fairfax County Deed Book 3099:251, October 21, 1968.
“Fairfax Squire Lived in Comfort: Six Beautiful Homes Typify Early 18th Century Rural Estates,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, April 27, 1941, p. 4.
 Federal Census of 1850 and 1860.
 Fairfax County Deed Book A2(27)186, December 1792.
 Fairfax County Personal Property Taxes of 1792 and 1793.
“The Gala on Friday Evening,” Alexandria Gazette, August 11, 1842, p. 3.
 Alexandria Gazette, August 2, 1823, p. 3.
 Federal Census of 1850.